Sekret by Lindsay Smith- Series Thoughts

Lindsay Smith's Sekret is a historical fantasy/science fiction novel duology taking place in 1964 and follows primarily Yulia Chernina, a Soviet girl who discovers that she has the ability to read minds. From there, she is taken by the KGB and trained as a spy to weed out Soviet dissenters and American spies. The first book, Sekret, takes place primarily in the Soviet Union, the second, Skandal, in America. Warning: the first book has a "love triangle" though it's fairly obvious who she'll end up with. Personally, I'm not too bothered by them myself, as I don't really see what's so rage-inducing about them- only time they piss me off is when the girl doesn't think she's attractive. But regardless, if you are a love triangle hater I'd skip this one if I were you and save yourself all the rage. 

I adore the covers of these books and they look fantastic together on my shelf. And the story idea is just as great. Seriously, Sekret went on my want list as soon as I heard the synopsis on Booktube- and I'm not a historical fantasy fan. But, sadly, both these books could have been so much better.

I did really enjoy the first book. It was fun and action packed and brainless, with a really great spy novel vibe. The second book... not so much. In fact, it was basically a repeat of the first book, but taking place in America now as opposed to the USSR. In fact, I would have been just fine with this book being a standalone, but hey, I suppose I should be happy with the fact that it was only a duology, and not an entire series or even a trilogy. Because fuck that. 

I also think that both these books didn't really have much staying power. I kind of got over Sekret in like a week and am sure that Skandal will go the same way. 

The characters were alright. I didn't really hate anyone, but the villains were fairly obvious and nothing anyone did really surprised me. In fact, as I really enjoyed the writing and the action, the characters actually ended up as the weak link in the story. Honestly, it's surprising that the books got as "high" scores from me as they did with such bad characters, because, while writing trumps both, I usually weight characters over plot.

I think I've made it clear that Sekret is my favorite book of the two. In fact, I recommend reading Sekret just as a standalone and not feeling forced, like I did, to read Skandal. Unless, of course, you like reading the same book over again, but in a different place. But for what it's worth, this duology is good slump reading, though they aren't masterpieces. For that purpose, I liked them just fine.

Sekret: 7.5-8 out of 10

Skandal: 6.5 out of 10

Overall Series Rating: 7 out of 10

Skandal by Lindsay Smith Review

WARNING: THERE MAY BE SPOILERS BELOW

“My past cannot hurt me now. My future cannot stop me now. All I have is now.”- Skandal, Lindsay Smith

My mind is mine alone.

Life in Washington, D.C., is not the safe haven Yulia hoped for when she risked everything to flee communist Russia. Her father is reckless and aloof, and Valentin is distant and haunted by his past. Her mother is being targeted by the CIA and the US government is suspicious of Yulia's allegiance. And when super-psychics start turning up in the US capitol, it seems that even Rostov is still a threat. Ultimately, Yulia must keep control of her own mind to save the people she loves and avoid an international Skandal.

If you'll recall, I quite liked Sekret. It was fun and action packed and helped me with my minor reading slump. I confess, though, I knew I wouldn't like this book as much as I liked the first. I wasn't looking forward to picking it up, but I decided to anyway because I didn't know what else to read and I figured this would be fun and action packed enough. 

This month I've been trying to read fun things to make up for last month. I've also been super busy, so don't expect much from me. 

However, Skandal didn't grab me the same way Sekret did. Maybe it's because I thought (and honestly still think) that Sekret didn't really need a second book. It was just fine on its own. It was just kind of the first book but taking place in America instead of the Soviet Union.

I did, however, enjoy the writing. I particularly liked Smith's descriptions, they were pretty and set the scene up nicely. Sure, the way the characters spoke seemed like it was right out of a 60s noir movie, but I managed to let myself enjoy it, even if it was a bit painful. 

Yulia was still the same okay main character. I still cared little for her and Valentin. The other characters didn't really interest me much and didn't do anything surprising to me. I just excused this as being a fun book and not one that was meant to be a literary masterpiece.

I do think that Smith went with the "everything but the kitchen sink" approach to historical fiction that I talked about in my A Death-Struck Year review. She threw in basically everything that people think of when they think of the 60s, and even a few of the 50s. Greasers, beatniks, Vietnam, Kennedy's assassination, the Cold War, mod clothing, the Beatles, the Civil Rights Movement, the Cuban Missile Crisis- whether it actually fit or not it was going in. Frankly, she should just have focused on the Cold War or maybe Vietnam or Cuba, to make for a more centered story. While I did like that scene in the jazz club, it felt a bit forced and not natural with the storyline.

The jazz club thing also fit into my other (nitpicky) complaint, which was what the hell where beatniks doing in 64? I know the Beat Generation was technically until the mid 60s, but by then it wasn't really relevant anymore, and the mod and Warhol's factory movements kind of took over the headlines. The true Beat Generation was in the 50s. Not to mention that beatniks and greasers didn't really party together. I was also a bit confused by how mod clothing was treated as this alien thing, when it was embraced by the youth in both America, Europe, and, yes, the Soviet Union in the 60s. Mod clothing wasn't some strange new thing. 

I also didn't like how Yulia's accent was mentioned every five lines. Yes, we get it, you're Russian, move on.

Overall I preferred the first book. I'm happy Smith didn't feel the need to drag it out any longer than two books, though, and I still want to read her other serial, but this book unfortunately kind of brought down the whole duology for me. I don't know if I'll write a series thoughts for this, but if I do, it will be up tomorrow. Hopefully. If I don't get distracted by Twin Peaks.

6.5 out of 10

Sekret by Lindsay Smith Review

WARNING: THERE MAY BE SPOILERS BELOW

“I am a puppet on Rostov's strings, and I will pay for serving god and country, if god is Karl Marx.”- Sekret, Lindsay Smith

An empty mind is a safe mind.

Yulia knows she must hide her thoughts and control her emotions to survive in Communist Russia. But if she sometimes manipulates the black market traders by reading their thoughts when she touches their skin, so what? Anything to help her survive.

Russia's powerful spy agency, the KGB, is recruiting young people with mind-reading capabilities for their psychic espionage program. Their mission: protect the Soviet space program from American CIA spies. Why shouldn't the KGB use any means necessary to make the young psychic cooperate? Anything to beat the American capitalist scum to the moon.

Yulia is a survivor. She won't be controlled by the KGB, who want to harness her abilities for the State with no regard for her own hopes and dreams. She won't let handsome Sergei plan her life as a member of elite Soviet society, or allow brooding Valentin to consume her with his dangerous mind and even more dangerous ideas. And she certainly won't become the next victim of the powerful American spy who can scrub a brain raw—and seems to be targeting Yulia.

Sorry about the dearth of reviews this month so far. A combination of minor reading slump and illness, this particular one giving me pounding headaches that make it hard for me to actually concentrate on anything. Happily, with the help of my best friend, ibuprofen, I was able to both start and finish Sekret by Lindsay Smith in one afternoon.

First, I have to laugh at the Elizabeth Wein review on the back of the book calling this a dystopian, though I admit that a popular historical fiction author- and one that I not only like but also recommend to people- calling a book that takes place in the USSR in the 60s a dystopian is a little depressing. This isn't a dystopian. I guess it can be considered a historical fantasy, or maybe historical science fiction, take your pick. It reminded me a bit of The Girl Who Could Fly (one of my favorite books as a child) crossed with a 60s Cold War spy novel. 

I enjoyed the writing, for the most part. Some parts were nicer than others, and it could use some polish, but I can see the writing turning into something really nice with the next book.

But I admit, most of the Cold War spy novel vibes I got came from the plot itself, though I did wish that carried over to the writing, since I probably would have gotten much more atmosphere and would have loved it much more easily. In that respect, this novel suffers from its first person perspective. I personally would have gone with a third person/omniscient perspective. I was hoping for something kind of like the Covert Front flash game series that Mateusz Skutnik makes. 

I mean, Yulia was an all right main character. I was able to get on board with her and Valentin- though he did sound too good to be true-, and wasn't too bothered by the love triangle (by the way, I don't really understand most people's burning hatred for love triangles, since I was never that bothered by them. I suppose it's one of those things that people find trendy to hate, like the word moist). It was too obvious who Yulia would end up with, and most of the drama in that respect was just annoying. I did like how Sergei wasn't made into a villain, though. 

The most developed characters were Yulia, Valentin, the Hound, and Sergei. Masha and Misha were as interchangeable as they come, Larissa had some glimmers of interesting features, and I kept forgetting Ivan existed. Krusenko was interesting, but not fully developed, and Rostov read like a parody of a villain from a anticommunist American cowboy show from the fifties, like something Bill Bryson would have made fun of in The Life and Times of the Thunderbolt Kid. 

So what did I like, besides the writing? Well, the idea is fan-freaking-tastic. You all know I stay away from historical fantasy, but I couldn't resist. I liked the action. And I admit, when you're sick, it's nice to sit back and pick up a fun, action-packed novel where you know that the good guys will win and the bad guys will lose. It was perfect the perfect sit-back-turn-brain-off kind of book. I loved the setting, and I wish there was more of the everyday Soviet life present. 

A few questions/nitpicks I have before I conclude. The Goodreads reviewer Khanh (the Grinch) in particular criticized her timeline when it comes to music. Apparently, Smith was off on the release dates of the Western music mentioned. She seems more knowledgeable than I am when it comes to 60s pop, so I take her word for it. While I do casually enjoy 60s bubblegum, especially on warm summer days, my regular taste in music is far from that kind of stuff (I like old music from the 20s-40s, show tunes- especially cabaret/vaudeville style, punk music, and alternative, if you were wondering) so I can't comment on the accuracy of that. 

No, most of my questions surround her parents. Now, Yulia's parents apparently used to be good, high up Party members. However, Yulia frequently mentions her parents, especially her father, criticizing Stalin and the other leaders of the Party as being cruel tyrants, and Yulia also seems to have very negative views of the Party. This wouldn't be that bad, if she doesn't specifically mention that her father apparently held these views when she was young, back when they were still good Party members. Yulia's parents likely shouldn't have had those beliefs, especially since they were their most successful during Stalin's reign of terror, and they were also Georgian, and Stalin especially favored his fellow Georgians. They couldn't have taught their children about the hardships of communism- that was just asking to be discovered and shot. I thought her actual family life was done in a very confusing manner anyway. It also annoyed me that Yulia seemed to have absolutely no loyalty to the USSR, when it would have been much more realistic if she had at least some sympathy to the country, especially since it would have been ingrained in her through her schooling.

I did really like this book, though. I was what I needed to get me out of a sick slump- some fun, action-packed book. I can see myself really enjoying this duology- I'm already looking forward to Skandal. But what can I say, this book was made for someone like me to love. It's no masterpiece, but it works for me. I do really want to pick up Smith's serial The Witch Who Came in from the Cold with Max Gladstone, or at least whenever the bindup comes out. 

7.5-8 out of 10