Showing posts with label nonfiction. Show all posts
Showing posts with label nonfiction. Show all posts

Sunday, December 17, 2017

The Road to Jonestown by Jeff Guinn Review

By the New York Times bestselling author of Manson, the comprehensive, authoritative, and tragic story of preacher Jim Jones, who was responsible for the Jonestown Massacre—the largest murder-suicide in American history.

In the 1950s, a young Indianapolis minister named Jim Jones preached a curious blend of the gospel and Marxism. His congregation was racially integrated, and he was a much-lauded leader in the contemporary civil rights movement. Eventually, Jones moved his church, Peoples Temple, to northern California. He became involved in electoral politics, and soon was a prominent Bay Area leader.

In this riveting narrative, Jeff Guinn examines Jones’s life, from his extramarital affairs, drug use, and fraudulent faith healing to the fraught decision to move almost a thousand of his followers to a settlement in the jungles of Guyana in South America. Guinn provides stunning new details of the events leading to the fatal day in November, 1978 when more than nine hundred people died—including almost three hundred infants and children—after being ordered to swallow a cyanide-laced drink.

Guinn examined thousands of pages of FBI files on the case, including material released during the course of his research. He traveled to Jones’s Indiana hometown, where he spoke to people never previously interviewed, and uncovered fresh information from Jonestown survivors. He even visited the Jonestown site with the same pilot who flew there the day that Congressman Leo Ryan was murdered on Jones’s orders. The Road to Jonestownis the definitive book about Jim Jones and the events that led to the tragedy at Jonestown.

This is probably the most hyped up nonfiction book of the year, and I have been wanting to read it since it came out. But every time I went to my library, the damn thing was checked out, until recently. Like most people, I don't really know much about Jonestown apart from the fact that it was a cult and Kool-Aid references (always wondered how that brand got away from that). Well, now I know more than I think I ever needed to about Jim Jones and his Peoples Temple.

I was also super impressed that Jim Jones Jr gave the book a positive review on the back. Blurbs never draw me because I rarely trust them, but Guinn definitely chose the right one to put on the back. 

I always thought it was funny that cults were a big thing in the 1960s, a time widely billed as the age of individuality, and also that those individuals were the ones to fall prey to cults. The Road to Jonestown reminded me of this because the main people Jones targeted weren't uneducated, backwoodsy people (usually the cult member stereotype) but instead urban blacks and college-educated whites who embraced him and the uneducated who viewed him with scorn. The book points us to the idea that he targeted the idealist in them, the people who fervently believe or want to believe in some ideal society. 

The book's biggest strength, though, is that it doesn't try and paint Jim Jones and by extension The Peoples Temple as being all bad, instead, it doesn't hesitate to show that there was a lot of good done by the people of The Peoples Temple. Jones' biggest failure, it would seem, was leaving Indianapolis. He did appear to have a genuine interest in helping raise people up, and he was an effective preacher. He could have become a white, 60s version of someone like Al Sharpton, and if he moved further down south he probably could have been even more successful (of course, this is all provided he got those serious mental problems under control). I mean, sure, maybe he wouldn't have been well liked and most people would still think of him as being a snake oil salesman, but what evangelist preacher isn't even a little bit shady? But once he left for Brazil and then California, everything fell apart for him.

This is an impeccably researched and easy to read nonfiction novel, a perfect one-stop book for those even a little bit interested in Jim Jones. Seriously, forget the Wikipedia page and YouTube documentaries, this book has everything you could ever want to know and much you didn't ever even need to know. Highly recommended.


9 out of 10

Friday, November 24, 2017

Shallow Graves by Maureen Boyle Review

Eleven women went missing over the spring and summer of 1988 in New Bedford, Massachusetts, an old fishing port known as the Whaling City, where Moby Dick, Frederick Douglass, textile mills, and heroin-dealing represent just a few of the many threads in the community's diverse fabric. In Shallow Graves, investigative reporter Maureen Boyle tells the story of a case that has haunted New England for thirty years.

The Crimes: The skeletal remains of nine of the women, aged nineteen to thirty-six, were discovered near highways around New Bedford. Some had clearly been strangled, others were so badly decomposed that police were left to guess how they had died.

The Victims: All the missing women had led troubled lives of drug addiction, prostitution, and domestic violence, including Nancy Paiva, whose sister was a hard-working employee of the City of New Bedford, and Debra Greenlaw DeMello, who came from a solidly middle-class family but fell into drugs and abusive relationships. In a bizarre twist, Paiva's clothes were found near DeMello's body.

The Investigators: Massachusetts state troopers Maryann Dill and Jose Gonsalves were the two constants in a complex cast of city, county, and state cops and prosecutors. They knew the victims, the suspects, and the drug-and-crime-riddled streets of New Bedford. They were present at the beginning of the case and they stayed to the bitter end.

The Suspects: Kenneth Ponte, a New Bedford attorney and deputy sheriff with an appetite for drugs and prostitutes, landed in the investigative crosshairs from the start. He was indicted by a grand jury in the murder of one of the victims, but those charges were later dropped. Anthony DeGrazia was a loner who appeared to fit the classic serial-killer profile: horrific childhood abuse, charming, charismatic, but prone to bursts of violence. He hunted prostitutes in the city by night and served at a Catholic church by day. Which of these two was the real killer? Or was it someone else entirely?

Maureen Boyle first broke the story in 1988 and stayed with it for decades. In Shallow Graves she spins a riveting narrative about the crimes, the victims, the hunt for the killers, and the search for justice, all played out against the backdrop of an increasingly impoverished community beset by drugs and crime. Drawing on more than one hundred interviews, along with police reports, first-person accounts, and field reporting both during the killings and more recently, Shallow Graves brings the reader behind the scenes of the investigation, onto the streets of the city, and into the homes of the families still hoping for answers.

I read a lot of true crime books, and yet most of the true crime stories I end up picking up take place in the past and are usually combined with historical elements- books like The Devil in the White City, or one I read this summer, City of Light, City of Poison. This is different, as it is only under the true crime label, being about a serial killer targeting drug-addicted women, usually prostitutes, in New Bedford Massachusetts, a quiet little seaside city populated mostly by, like many Southern New England fishing cities, people of Portuguese descent. You get a lot of those ethnic pockets of people in New England, usually from countries you don't think too much about like Portugal or Greece or Poland or even Italy. 

Well, I suppose it's not exactly only a true crime book since it is during the 80s, and there is some context about the time period that needs to be understood. Most people think of cocaine as the rock star drug of the decade, taking LSD's place before it was usurped by ecstasy in the 90s, but the heroin epidemic really started to get bad in the 80s, unfortunately coinciding with the AIDS crisis, as any ER nurse or doctor active in that time period will tell you. Like in today's society, when pain pill addiction progresses to heroin addiction, in the 80s it was cocaine addiction progressing to heroin addiction. And those where the women our killer chose his victims from.

Shallow Graves is written like a mystery novel is, especially the prologue. In fact, the prologue is what lured me in to the book. I wasn't sure if I would like it- I wasn't too crazy about the synopsis- but I decided to read it many because, again, the first page and also because it was short and I wanted to at least make my average for this month. 

Like in the case for many nonfiction novels, I don't really know what to say about it except that I liked it. It was okay, not my favorite nonfiction book I've read this year, but I'm happy I read it. Just a warning though, the ending is a little... unsatisfactory, to say the least, but I enjoyed Shallow Graves enough to recommend it to any causal and more serious true crime fan alike.

8 out of 10

Tuesday, October 31, 2017

The Victorian Book of the Dead Edited by Chris Woodyard Review

Chris Woodyard, author of the The Ghosts of the Past series, digs through long-buried newspapers and journals, for this fascinating look at the 19th-century obsession with the culture of death. The Victorian Book of the Dead unearths extraordinary tales of Victorian funeral fads and fancies, ghost stories, bizarre deaths, mourning novelties, gallows humor, premature burial, post-mortem photographs, death omens, and funeral disasters. Resurrected from original sources, these accounts reveal the oddities and eccentricities of Victorian mourning. Packed with macabre anecdotes, this diverting, yet gruesome collection presents tales ranging from the paranormal and shocking to the heartbreaking.

Happy Halloween! This is the first year I'm not doing anything for the holiday beyond rewatching the Halloween episodes of Bob's Burgers and How I Met Your Mother and listening to The Amphibious Man on Bandcamp since I have other things going on in the coming days that require my attention, but it's still my favorite holiday, something that's fairly obvious given my taste in humor and literature borders on the dark side. Like this book, which I was saving exclusively for Halloween.

This isn't a fine, serious work of nonfiction. Instead, it's more on par with the fun to read and vaguely trashy nonfiction like the book Weird New Jersey and its many spinoffs. It's made up of newspaper articles and commentary from the Victorian times detailing their quite morbid culture of death, something that the Victorians were notorious for. In this book, Woodyard discusses everything from death photography to being buried alive to the clothing mourners wore and the Victorian strive to do everything, including mourning, properly. 

My favorite chapter was probably the chapter Died of Lizards, about strange ways Victorians met their ends, including by a gas addicted bird, 2 women who lost everyone in their family within a span of a very short time (in one case, her child was struck by the hearse carrying her husband), and "the effects of 'skipping the rope'." whatever the hell that means. There's something very Gorey-esque about these stories, and it reminded me of two of his short stories in particular- The Gashlycrumb Tinies (obviously), and The Hapless Child. What really takes the cake about these stories is dry way the reporters comment on these strange demises. Needless to say, I found them hilarious.

The fashion historian in me also feels the need comment on how much I liked the chapter Crape too. It's got lots of fun details on the garments worn by mourners.

The Victorian Book of the Dead is a coffee table book that also happens to have some great information on Victorian death. And, of course, it's the perfect book to read on a chilly, October night. Recommended.


8 out of 10

Saturday, October 28, 2017

Salaam, Love edited by Ayesha Mattu and Nura Maznavi Mini Review

From the editors of the groundbreaking anthology Love, InshAllah comes a provocative new exploration of the most intimate parts of Muslim mens lives. Muslim men are stereotyped as either oversexed Casanovas willing to die for seventy-two virgins in heaven or controlling, big-bearded husbands ready to rampage at the hint of dishonor. The truth is, there are millions of Muslim men trying to figure out the complicated terrain of love, sex, and relationships just like any other American man. In Salaam, Love, Ayesha Mattu and Nura Maznavi provide a space for American Muslim men to speak openly about their romantic lives, offering frank, funny, and insightful glimpses into their hearts-and bedrooms. The twenty-two writers come from a broad spectrum of ethnic, racial, and religious perspectives-including orthodox, cultural, and secular Muslims-reflecting the strength and diversity of their faith community and of America. By raising their voices to share stories of love and heartbreak, loyalty and betrayal, intimacy and insecurity, these Muslim men are leading the way for all men to recognize that being open and honest about their feelings is not only okay-its intimately connected to their lives and critical to their happiness and well-being.

This is an anthology of Muslim American men talking about their experiences with romance, something I likely wouldn't have picked up if I didn't have a class that made this required reading. Not that I have any problem with the subject matter, but because, like most people, I have middling luck with anthologies. In fact, I don't know anyone who actively seeks out anthologies or even really likes them. Most people I know just buy them because they like or recognize one or two of the authors and figured what the hell. 

The problem with anthologies is that, for every great entry, there's a dud. In this book, I found some stories I really liked and connected with, and some I didn't care for at all. Some of the writers had wonderfully distinct voices- especially the African American writers- some did not. Some I found sweet and endearing, some I did not. Like with many anthologies, I only really liked one or two and, on the flip side, only really hated one or two. Otherwise, I felt pretty lukewarm on most of them. 

It is interesting to hear Muslim men speak on their beliefs about love, especially since I rarely hear from male Muslims. Sure, there's books like The Kite Runner, but I find that most Muslim books published in America are written by women and from a female point of view, and unfortunately, Muslim men are often villianized. So I liked that aspect. And the anthology is easy to read, most of the voices present striking me as the kind of people I'd probably hang out with in real life if given the chance. I don't know if I really understand the inner lives of Muslim men after reading this, but it was interesting enough if just for the peek into the lives of others. What can I say, I like that kind of stuff.


8 out of 10 

Saturday, September 16, 2017

The Fact of a Body by Alexandria Marzano-Lesnevich Review

Before Alexandria Marzano-Lesnevich begins a summer job at a law firm in Louisiana, working to help defend men accused of murder, she thinks her position is clear. The child of two lawyers, she is staunchly anti-death penalty. But the moment convicted murderer Ricky Langley’s face flashes on the screen as she reviews old tapes―the moment she hears him speak of his crimes―she is overcome with the feeling of wanting him to die. Shocked by her reaction, she digs deeper and deeper into the case. Despite their vastly different circumstances, something in his story is unsettlingly, uncannily familiar.

Crime, even the darkest and most unsayable acts, can happen to any one of us. As Alexandria pores over the facts of the murder, she finds herself thrust into the complicated narrative of Ricky’s childhood. And by examining the details of Ricky’s case, she is forced to face her own story, to unearth long-buried family secrets, and reckon with a past that colors her view of Ricky's crime.

But another surprise awaits: She wasn’t the only one who saw her life in Ricky’s.

An intellectual and emotional thriller that is also a different kind of murder mystery, The Fact Of a Body is a book not only about how the story of one crime was constructed―but about how we grapple with our own personal histories. Along the way it tackles questions about the nature of forgiveness, and if a single narrative can ever really contain something as definitive as the truth. This groundbreaking, heart-stopping work, ten years in the making, shows how the law is more personal than we would like to believe―and the truth more complicated, and powerful, than we could ever imagine.
 

The nonfiction books I've been picking up lately have been especially good, and continuing that winning streak we have The Fact of a Body. This was one of two extremely hyped up nonfiction crime novels this year, and it seemed much much more interesting than the other one, American Fire, about arson, a crime even more boring than money laundering or other financial crimes. Also, it's by the same author as one of my least favorite books last year. So when looking at both books in the library I only came home with one, this one.

The Fact of the Body is kind of in the same tradition as In Cold Blood, looking at a heinous crime and then looking at the man who committed such an act. Both crimes are roughly on the same side of horrible, the men in In Cold Blood killing four people, including two teenagers, in a home invasion and the man in this book killing a child after maybe sexually assaulting him. Or perhaps he killed the child and then sexually assaulted him. The details were never really worked out. I put these two crimes on the same level because crimes against children are hideous no question. 

After Marzano-Lesnevich establishes the crime and the crime's effects on the people of the town, like Capote she then launches into Ricky Smith's (the man who did it) past. There could be strong parallels drawn between him and Perry Smith. Both come from less than ideal home lives, big families with alcoholic mothers. Both have less than normal mental states, there is something easily pitied about them. While it was easier to pity Perry than Ricky, I can't help but feel something for them both. Of course, I've always been sensitive to people who come across as sad or desperate or childish seeming. I mean, I've been watching The People vs OJ Simpson and I just feel bad for everyone in that show except Shapiro and Cochlan. So really, it's not that hard to garner my pity, I'm pretty susceptible to sob stories, it's mostly why I oppose the death penalty. That being said, I'm not saying that Ricky Smith should be free or be in a mental institution instead of jail, no the man belongs in prison for life, no questions asked, but he doesn't deserve to die.

An interesting question that this book brings up is the question of pedophilia. Can a person with it get help? Can they change? Or are they people who just can't help themselves? I'm not a psychologist, far from it actually, but I don't think they can change. On one hand, the book leads you to pity the pedophile, who tried to get help only to have it fail, but on the other hand... pedophiles hurt children. They aren't kleptomaniacs who don't actually hurt anyone. Children do not and never will understand sex or romantic love, you cannot be in a mutual relationship with a five year old. In the end, I think there is nothing to do but put the pedophile in jail.

Also, I'm pretty sure Ricky Smith has some form of Fetal Alcohol Syndrome. The childish, impulsive way he acts certainly points to that, especially since his mother apparently drank steadily throughout her entire pregnancy.

However, I wasn't as taken with the memoir part of the book as I was with the crime part, though I'm sure it was very cathartic to write. 

Marzano-Lesnevich is a very good writer, one who definitely knows how to tell a story, and I can see her going far in the literary world. I liked her style, and how she endeavors to show all sides of the story, and her own perspective on her childhood abuse. While she doesn't claim to speak for all those who were abused as children, likely this book will be very helpful for someone who went through something similar.

In the end, I highly recommend this book to someone who likes crime books or family dramas or both, regardless of which side one falls on the death penalty. I will definitely watch for more of Alexandria Marzano-Lesnevich's work.

8.5 out of 10

Friday, September 8, 2017

Five Favorites- Nonfiction

I love nonfiction. Despite this, I don't really reach for it a lot, and my nonfiction favorites have pretty much stayed the same since I first started seriously reading the genre. In fact, I kinda wish I could add more than five to this list, because if I could books like Dave Cullen's Columbine or Elie Wiesel's Night or even Legs McNeil and Gillian McCain's Please Kill Me would make the list. But alas, it must only be five. 

So here are my five favorites in nonfiction, in no particular order.


1. Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil by John Berendt

   This is not only my favorite nonfiction novel, but also one of my favorite books of all time. I know this isn't the most factual book ever, and a lot is switched around or fabricated for the sake of the story, but I loved it regardless. The characters, the mystery, the fact that it takes place in one of my favorite cities ever all make this book a really, really great read. It's about a New York journalist who falls in love with the city of Savannah, Georgia, and ends up temporarily moving there, meeting all these unusual people and ends up getting involved with a crime taking place there. It's at times both sad and laugh out loud funny, and has such a diverse cast of characters, including The Grand Empress of Savannah, The Lady Chablis, who unfortunately died last September. 


2. The Diary of a Young Girl (definitive edition) by Anne Frank
   Of course the diary of Anne Frank would have to be on this list. I read this one when I was about 12 or 13, because my mom told me to. I didn't feel compelled to pick it up until my seventh grade class read her diary without actually reading it if you can believe that and my mother told me I should read the actual book. And I really, really loved it. It's not really a preachy or moralistic book about loving everyone, the way those selected quotes from it might make you think. In fact, reading her book kind of brings her back down to Earth. She isn't some legendary, visionary girl. Instead, she's a teenager, a girl who's sometimes moody, sometimes funny, sometimes insightful. I was surprised by how deeply I could relate to her diary, to the loneliness she felt and her longings for a best friend or a boyfriend. If anyone is curious at all into the inner workings of the mind of a teenage girl, they should read this novel. I specified the edition I own and love because it's the book that mirrors her own edits of the book as opposed to the ones done by her father, which heavily censored many aspects of the diary. If you haven't read this book yet, please do.


3. In Cold Blood by Truman Capote
   Little known fact about me, Truman Capote is one of my favorite authors. He is the master of the short story, and Breakfast at Tiffany's is a novella I hold dear to my heart- I'd recommend it provided you don't hold any particular attachment to the movie. Truman Capote is also a pretty interesting guy himself, and the backstory behind In Cold Blood has filled books and provided fodder for two pretty phenomenal movies (of those Capote is the deeper, better movie, but Infamous is worth watching for a more skin deep take on the story- and also for the sheer amount of talent in that movie: Sandra Bullock, one of the James Bond guys, Isabella Rossellini, etc). But anyway, In Cold Blood. This book is a must read for any true crime fan, a phenomenal exploration into the minds of two criminals who killed a family in Kansas for fifty bucks. The horrors of their crimes are not shied away from, but there is an undeniably human side to them portrayed. This is a truly revolutionary work, and one many crime novels have endeavored to emulate. Again, any nonfiction lover, and especially nonfiction crime enthusiast, should read this book. 


4. The Life and Times of the Thunderbolt Kid by Bill Bryson
   This appears to be Bill Bryson's least known book, which depresses me. I'm not one for memoirs, but this book is truly wonderful. It's about Bryson growing up in the 50s in Des Moines, Iowa, and is both educational and personal. It's one of the funniest books I've ever read- my mother and I quote still quote from it- including one of my favorite scenes in the history of literature- I'd type it here, but it involves a racial slur- thought NOT IN A RACIST CONTEXT. I did, however, almost piss my pants when I read it the first time. Still, this book has the same effect on me that my favorite Woody Allen movie, Radio Days, had, funny, sweet, and an ending that never fails to bring me to tears all in one book.


5. The Devil in the White City by Erik Larson
   Here's another true crime classic, The Devil in the White City. This is history told in an accessible way, one that seamlessly blends fact and narrative to create a wonderful story about both an architect, the visionary behind the 1892 Chicago World's Fair, and America's first serial killer, whose chosen victims came from the fair. Naturally, to me the serial killer's parts were more interesting, but the actual coming together of the fair and the history of Chicago, that turbulent city on Lake Michigan, and one I personally love, is quite fascinating in its own right. If you haven't read this book yet, please pick it up.

What are some of your favorite nonfiction books? Have you read any of these books? What do you think about them? Leave your thoughts below!

Wednesday, August 23, 2017

Bear in the Streets by Lisa Dickey Review

Lisa Dickey traveled across the whole of Russia three times—in 1995, 2005 and 2015—making friends in eleven different cities, then coming back again and again to see how their lives had changed. Like the acclaimed British documentary series Seven Up!, she traces the ups and downs of ordinary people’s lives, in the process painting a deeply nuanced portrait of modern Russia.

From the caretakers of a lighthouse in Vladivostok, to the Jewish community of Birobidzhan, to a farmer in Buryatia, to a group of gay friends in Novosibirsk, to a wealthy “New Russian” family in Chelyabinsk, to a rap star in Moscow, Dickey profiles a wide cross-section of people in one of the most fascinating, dynamic and important countries on Earth. Along the way, she explores dramatic changes in everything from technology to social norms, drinks copious amounts of vodka, and learns firsthand how the Russians really feel about Vladimir Putin.

Including powerful photographs of people and places over time, and filled with wacky travel stories, unexpected twists, and keen insights, Bears in the Streets offers an unprecedented on-the-ground view of Russia today.

I hate writing nonfiction reviews. What's more, I hate writing reviews for nonfiction books I like. Because I genuinely enjoyed this novel and I have no idea what to say about it. 

It was a smartly written, entertaining novel about the everyday people of Russia, told through the perspective of a remarkably unbiased American woman. I picked it up primarily because I'm a russophile, and the summary intrigued me. I was curious to see how Russia evolved in modern times, especially since most of what I've read about Russia is primarily from the modern times. In some ways, it reminded me of A Constellation of Vital Phenomena and a lot of The Tsar of Love and Techno, especially the parts about the Chechen war. 

While I don't know if I'd be as attracted to this novel if it wasn't about Russia, it did, kind of unexpectedly, satisfy the observer in me. The person who is fascinated by other people and the different lives other people live, especially those so radically different than my own. It reminded me of why I love books like Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil- the crime in that book is fascinating, but what interests me more is the people Berendt comes across. It's the same thing that always draws me to blogs and YouTube channels and the like. I just like knowing how other people live.

And again, the narrator is relatively unbiased. She's got a good balancing act. She definitely has a presence in the book, even more so than Berendt had in his book, with at several times her opinions being made clear, but she doesn't really look down on others for having differing opinions and at one point even comes to the conclusion that the Russians might even be more tolerant than she is- they were able to separate her from her opinions and her government, where as she was having a hard time separating them from their feelings and their government. 

Dickey also does a good job showing the political opinions of modern Russia, and interestingly, they are the opposite of what some Americans may think they are. I find that quite a few Americans are convinced that the Russian everyday people hate Putin and their government and are only going along with it because they fear the repercussions. Of course, this is mostly true of liberals; conservatives have the tendency to think all Russians are still goddamn commies at heart. However, when Dickey traveled across Russia, she found that, nope, the Russian people just like Putin, even the young ones. I think that, in the end, just like France is more liberal than we are, Russia's just more conservative than we are. I'm not really sure why we are surprised or questioning why a guy like Putin got into power, or why he's so beloved by the people. Russia's always been ruled by leaders like that, and when a moderate comes into power, he's always overthrown or elected out or whatever. Think about it. They went from autocrats to Communists, you think our brand of Democratic Republicanism has a hope in hell of working for them. Then again, I typically believe that most countries have the government they deserve, yes, even America, especially America actually, and I'm weirdly non-fatalistic when it comes to governments (this is weird because I can't get on a plane without thinking that I'm going to die at any second but I just can't bring myself to feel like Doomsday is nigh about the next four years, because America's dealt with worse and we will come out it just fine. I mean, we managed to survive the 70s and the Carter administration, we can survive this).

Wow, that got political. Let's pretend that never happened. Anyway, yes, I liked this book. It was sweet in a lot of ways, like during the many reunion scenes, and sad in others, like the Mother of a Soldier chapter. It's a fascinating tale of three very timely periods in Modern Russian history, and I can't help but wish a little that her final trip was in the year 2017 because, well, I want to know what the Russian everyday man thinks about today's political turmoil.

9 out of 10

Sunday, August 13, 2017

The Romanov Sisters by Helen Rappaport Review

They were the Princess Dianas of their day—perhaps the most photographed and talked about young royals of the early twentieth century. The four captivating Russian Grand Duchesses—Olga, Tatiana, Maria and Anastasia Romanov—were much admired for their happy dispositions, their looks, the clothes they wore and their privileged lifestyle.

Over the years, the story of the four Romanov sisters and their tragic end in a basement at Ekaterinburg in 1918 has clouded our view of them, leading to a mass of sentimental and idealized hagiography. With this treasure trove of diaries and letters from the grand duchesses to their friends and family, we learn that they were intelligent, sensitive and perceptive witnesses to the dark turmoil within their immediate family and the ominous approach of the Russian Revolution, the nightmare that would sweep their world away, and them along with it.

The Romanov Sisters sets out to capture the joy as well as the insecurities and poignancy of those young lives against the backdrop of the dying days of late Imperial Russia, World War I and the Russian Revolution. Rapport aims to present a new and challenging take on the story, drawing extensively on previously unseen or unpublished letters, diaries and archival sources, as well as private collections. It is a book that will surprise people, even aficionados

It's a rite of passage for any history loving little girl to go through a go through a phrase in which she is obsessed with a royal family. And, apart from a brief phrase in 7th grade when I was super into Elizabeth I and the rest of the Tudors, my heart belonged to the Romanov family, more specifically the last Romanovs, the Imperial family of Tsar Nicholas II. And, like most girls getting into the Romanovs, my obsession lied with the youngest and arguably the most famous, Anastasia. I always liked the tragedy behind her story, how she was this happy young girl until the Soviets shot her a cold basement. As I've been getting older, my interest in her dwindled and turned towards her mother, because she's easily one of the most interesting females in all of history, and lately I've been getting more and more into the Soviets. But let it be known that the catalyst to my Russian obsession is the last Grand Duchess of all of Russia. 

Rappaport's The Romanov Sisters is, as you can imagine, perfect for anyone who wants information on just the Grand Duchesses and not necessarily Alexei's hemophilia or Rasputin or the Imperial Couple. Sure, they are mentioned but only in regards to how the sisters were impacted by them. In that respect I think this is the first. One of the reasons for my interest turning towards Alexandra in the first place was because of the abundance of books on her and lack of books on the Grand Duchesses. Hell, I think there are more books on Anna Anderson, who pretended to be Anastasia, than Anastasia herself. Of course, after reading this book, I can understand why not many people tackle the topic of the Grand Duchesses. There isn't really much information exclusively on the girls. The public at the time was captivated by Alexei, and now a days, most historians are more interested in their mother or Rasputin than anyone else. Especially Rasputin. Me, can't say I was ever that intrigued by him. 

One of the things Rappaport does well is capture the girls as individuals, not just OTMA or the Big Pair and Little Pair. Olga is the sensitive, melancholy one with a hot temper, Tatiana is the reserved beauty, her mother's favorite, Maria is the romantic middle child who often felt left out, Anastasia is the trickster youngest. Clearly, Rappaport made it her mission not to lump the girls into one, and I think she did it well. 

Nicholas and Alexandra are shown in a different light here than in most Romanov books. Nicholas is an excellent father, devoted to his girls despite them being, well, girls, Alexandra's hypochondriac qualities aren't smothered, but as a whole I think this is the most positive portrayal of her I've ever seen. Say what you will about her, but she was an excellent mother and a far more devoted one than many royal families had during the time. 

But, even before the Revolution, the Romanovs were a tragic family, and Rappaport doesn't shy away from showing that. There's the girls' sub-par education, their sheltered existence in perpetual fear of one of Alexei's attacks. It's depressing, really, that these girls never could have a normal life for someone of their class, despite having all the wealth and privilege in the world. The term "gilded cage" applies well here, I think.

As a whole, this is a wonderful book for someone interested in the Romanov girls, and it is remarkable what Rappaport can come up with despite having limited resources to work with. She has successfully renewed my interest in the Romanov family, and I am tempted now to pick up her other book, The Last Days of the Romanovs.


9 out of 10

Tuesday, July 25, 2017

City of Light, City of Poison by Holly Tucker Review

Appointed to conquer the “crime capital of the world,” the first police chief of Paris faces an epidemic of murder in the late 1600s. Assigned by Louis XIV, Nicolas de La Reynie begins by clearing the streets of filth and installing lanterns throughout Paris, turning it into the City of Light.

The fearless La Reynie pursues criminals through the labyrinthine neighborhoods of the city. He unearths a tightly knit cabal of poisoners, witches, and renegade priests. As he exposes their unholy work, he soon learns that no one is safe from black magic—not even the Sun King. In a world where a royal glance can turn success into disgrace, the distance between the quietly back-stabbing world of the king’s court and the criminal underground proves disturbingly short. Nobles settle scores by employing witches to craft poisons and by hiring priests to perform dark rituals in Paris’s most illustrious churches and cathedrals.

As La Reynie continues his investigations, he is haunted by a single question: Could Louis’s mistresses could be involved in such nefarious plots? The pragmatic and principled La Reynie must decide just how far he will go to protect his king.

From secret courtrooms to torture chambers, City of Light, City of Poison is a gripping true-crime tale of deception and murder. Based on thousands of pages of court transcripts and La Reynie’s compulsive note-taking, as well as on letters and diaries, Tucker’s riveting narrative makes the fascinating, real-life characters breathe on the page.

This has been the year of mediocre nonfiction. None of the books I read were real standouts, despite the fact I did like most of them. But this book. This is the book I wished The Poisoner's Handbook was. I mean, I was happy enough with The Poisoner's Handbook as is, but I loved this one. It reminded me of the way Erik Larsen (of The Devil in the White City fame) writes.

I admit, though, when I first started the parts about Louis XIV's mistresses, I was a bit skeptical. For one thing, this book was not advertised as being about that, and didn't know how well Holly Tucker was going to connect it with the main story. While the connection was, in fact, tenuous, I was still fascinated by the dramatic stories about Louis XIV's mistresses. I felt like I was watching some trashy reality TV show, but a 100 times better because it's about one of the most powerful rulers in French history. I get that some people might be bored by these parts, but I personally really loved them.

And besides, the actual poison stuff was extremely easy to read, as well as the bits about the reform of Paris and the Parisian prison system. It was especially interesting to read about how coroners, often just surgeons or doctors back then, no special training was required to become one, were able to tell how people died just by basic scientific intuition. There were no fancy tests done to tell whether someone died of arsenic or snake venom, instead, they had to compare the effects of that specific poison to an already deceased confirmed poisoned body and tell by that. I always liked reading how people make do with what they have, especially in the days before technology.

And I ended up really liking Nicolas de la Reynie as a main character. He was the kind of guy you'd want to root for in detective novels, someone whose relentless pursual of the truth is admirable. He was truly one of a kind for his time period, especially since he didn't let class stand in the way of justice. While it is true that many of the noblewomen involved in the poison cases he studied did have more cushy prison lives than the women in the Third Estate who were arrested for the same crimes, and some of them got off on lighter sentences, he didn't wave their cases under the rug, and it's entirely likely he was frustrated by the inability of the Arsenal judges to see that a noblewoman of high birth could have committed such heinous crimes. And the cushy prison existence these women led was a matter of necessity, he knew that if he treated them cruelly then he would get nowhere and even perhaps be forced out of his job. De la Reynie really was one of the first in believing that justice is blind.

And oddly, I did still really like certain parts I probably would have hated if they were in a fictional book. For instance, I thought Mary-Anne Mancini was freaking bad-ass, to say the least. Her responses to the judges and her showing up with her husband in one hand and her boy-toy nephew in the other cracked me up. I wouldn't mind reading a book on her, and perhaps the rest of the Mancinis as well.

While reading I couldn't help but think of The Gentleman's Guide to Vice and Virtue, probably because both books took place roughly around the same time and some of the subject matter reminded me of it. And frankly, this book is what The Gentleman's Guide should have been like. It didn't need any strange Marina-esque plot or pirates or highwaymen to be interesting. In fact, I was actually a lot more entertained by this work of pure nonfiction than I was by that work of what is advertised as YA fluff fiction. The juicy stuff in here- the sex, the torture (prison torture before execution, not sex torture), the poison- is all stuff that could have been included in The Gentleman's Guide- well, maybe not the torture, but the sex and poison could have been wonderful. Hell, maybe Lee should have dropped the odd alchemy plot and gone with one based on the Affaire des Poisons. I mean, sure, she would have had to push it up a few decades from the late 1670s, early 1680s to the 1720s, but I could have forgiven that if it was based in something as interesting and little known to the general public as this instead of her going with basic early 18th century pop history- alchemy, pirates, Scientific Revolution/Enlightenment, Spain vs France (well, really England by proxy vs France). 

After reading this book I feel the sudden craving to read nonfiction. It happens sometimes, usually after I've finished a really good one. This is my favorite type of nonfiction to read- true, historical crime. Think the stuff Erik Larsen usually writes. The best of both worlds to me, especially since lately I've been unenthused with regular true crime nonfiction. I mean, when the most popular true crime book out now is about a string of arsons that happened to abandoned places nobody cares about with the main message being roughly the same thing that's been said over and over again, you have to wonder about the future of the genre. That being said, I am waiting for my library to get a copy of Killers of the Flower Moon, since I've been vaguely interested in that ever since it came out in April. Still, I'm actually in the mood to read, something I honestly haven't felt at all this month.


9 out of 10

Friday, July 21, 2017

The Dead Inside by Cyndy Elter Review

I never was a badass. Or a slut, a junkie, a stoner, like they told me I was. I was just a kid looking for something good, something that felt like love. I was a wannabe in a Levi's jean jacket. Anybody could see that. Except my mother. And the professionals at Straight.

From the outside, Straight Inc. was a drug rehab. But on the inside it was...well, it was something else.

All Cyndy wanted was to be loved and accepted. By age fourteen, she had escaped from her violent home, only to be reported as a runaway and sent to a "drug rehabilitation" facility that changed her world.

To the public, Straight Inc. was a place of recovery. But behind closed doors, the program used bizarre and intimidating methods to "treat" its patients. In her raw and fearless memoir, Cyndy Etler recounts her sixteen months in the living nightmare that Straight Inc. considered "healing."

Fun fact, I found this book in the local library thinking it was fiction, because it's in the fiction section. It's not. It's a memoir. But it is written like a fiction novel which makes me think fiction is in this author's future. 

In this case, the fictional feel of the memoir made it easy to read and hard to put down. I read the whole thing in one sitting, intrigued by the fucked up nature of Straight Inc. Young Cyndy was an interesting narrator, and I liked the 80s slang that peppered her voice. Also, she gets bonus points for actually managing to sound her age in the memoir. Cyndy actually seemed 13-14, not 8. I find that a lot of YA authors when writing a character that's younger than 15 make them sound like they're fresh out of elementary school, not middle school- see The Perks of Being a Wallflower. Cyndy was believable as an 80s young teen- I could imagine her with her big 80s hair and jean jacket giggling about boys at the mall with Joanna.

I also loved that it took partly in Connecticut. I didn't expect it too, and thought it was just a coincidence when Bridgeport was mentioned. But then Stamford and Norwalk and Monroe showed up, and I kind of loved that I knew everything she was talking about. I'm happy this book showed a different Connecticut than the one that usually shows up in books. Fairfield County, Greenwich, Westport, rich areas with Old Money WASPish families and the only cotillion classes available this side of the Mason-Dixon Line. Either that or charming colonial-era towns populated by lovable eccentrics straight out of Gilmore Girls. In reality, while it is true Connecticut is home to some of the richest area codes in the country and has plenty of picturesque small towns, there's a huge wealth divide, and many of the major cities are Not the Best Places to Live as a result. I mean, sure, there's a couple of exceptions- Trumbull's pretty nice for instance- but Bridgeport, New Haven (there's a reason most of the Yalies live in Woodbridge), and Hartford are pretty bad places to be late at night. We also have a lot of rural towns and old blue collar mill towns that have picked themselves back up by varying degrees after industry left America. My point is, Cyndy paints a good portrait of what the real Connecticut is. Her descriptions of Monroe as a Podunk town especially made me laugh- Monroe's on the edge of the rural area- it's not really rural, but I could see how someone from Stamford would think that. 

This book also probably contains the most glowing description of Bridgeport you will ever find. Seriously. My mother grew up in Trumbull, on the Bridgeport border actually, and worked there as an ER nurse during the AIDS epidemic- right around the time this book takes place- and the stories she could tell you. Bridgeport's probably like the estranged delinquent child of Fairfield County. I think because of that I really liked the way Cyndy thought of the city. Because Bridgeport's kind of like an amped up version of all those old mill towns. Once upon a time, it made everything from corsets to guns. It's home to PT Barnum, the Frisbie Pie Company (where the name Frisbee comes from), and Subway and what would the world be like without those things. But it got hit hard by deindustrialization and I'm afraid it hasn't changed much since '85, the year this memoir was supposed to take place. I suppose they're trying to fix it, but this is also the city that, two years ago, elected a guy as mayor who got arrested for corruption the last time he served, so I'm not really holding my breath.

Sorry, I get a little carried away with stuff like that. 

Anyway, one thing I didn't think worked entirely about this memoir is the way she switched tenses a lot, making me confused when an event took place. In fact, the whole time frame of this memoir once she got into Straight was a bit hard to follow. She would make references about events that happened "last night" even though she didn't write about them when they actually happened and, again, her tenses would get all mixed up and I'd just end up confused. Luckily, it was easy enough to not fixate on and I was able to get the gist of what was going on. Because once you get past those minor issues, the book becomes easy to read- and an interesting one at that.

So I did enjoy The Dead Inside. I mean, I didn't love it or anything, but I did find it absolutely fascinating and liked Cyndy enough. I'd recommend it if you want an easy to read memoir with an interesting subject matter.


8 out of 10

Wednesday, May 31, 2017

The AIDS Generation by Perry N Halkitis Review


For young gay men who came of age in the United States in the 1980s, the HIV/AIDS epidemic was a formative experience in fear, hardship, and loss. Those who were diagnosed before 1996 suffered an exceptionally high rate of mortality, and the survivors -- both the infected individuals and those close to them -- today constitute a "bravest generation" in American history.

The AIDS Generation: Stories of Survival and Resilience examines the strategies for survival and coping employed by these HIV-positive gay men, who together constitute the first generation of long-term survivors of the disease. Through interviews conducted by the author, it narrates the stories of gay men who have survived since the early days of the epidemic; documents and delineates the strategies and behaviors enacted by men of this generation to survive it; and examines the extent to which these approaches to survival inform and are informed by the broad body of literature on resilience and health.

The stories and strategies detailed here, all used to combat the profound physical, emotional, and social challenges faced by those in the crosshairs of the AIDS epidemic, provide a gateway for understanding how individuals cope with chronic and life-threatening diseases. Halkitis takes readers on a journey of first-hand data collection (the interviews themselves), the popular culture representations of these phenomena, and his own experiences as one of the men of the AIDS generation.

This riveting account will be of interest to health practitioners and historians throughout the clinical and social sciences -- or to anyone with an interest in this important chapter in social history.


This book took me about forever to read. I started it sometime after Tell the Wolves I'm Home, because I thought it was fitting, and put it down, picking it up again at the beginning of the month and spent the rest of the month trying to read it.

It's not that this was a bad book, not at all. In fact, it was an interesting look at the AIDS epidemic from the eyes of men who, while being HIV positive, did not yet get full-blown AIDS. I could tell how passionate Halkitis was about helping those with the disease, and his interviews with the men seemed to actually help them.

But I'm not a science person, at all, and the writing was very scientific. I wanted more from the actual stories of the men than I got, and was quickly sick of the repetition in the book. Some of the men were referenced more than others, and I sometimes had a hard time keeping them all straight. I think I also read the term "youth-obsessed culture" like five times over the span of two pages once. But at the same time, this is all personal preference. This isn't a novel, it's more along the same lines as a study published in an academic journal. It's not supposed to be artfully written. 

The subject matter is fascinating, though, and I enjoyed reading about the AIDS epidemic from those who were involved in it but didn't perish. I especially liked the parts about the modern gay community, a community often romanticized or portrayed as this flawless, unconditionally accepting community when in reality, it's not anymore. In a lot of respects, the gay community in the 21st century is like mainstream society, in which youth is put on a pedestal and even 50 year olds are labelled as out of touch with reality and treated with disrespect despite whatever they've been through. It's all so depressingly vapid, and I felt bad for the men in the book for having to deal with this in even the place they once felt like they fit in. In some respects, they reminded me of WWII or Korea vets in nursing homes, though perhaps Vietnam might be a better comparison. Of course, I say all the above as a straight white girl, albeit one who has done her research.

So everything I got out of the book was great, but the process of reading it was painful, to say the least. I kind of hit that treadmill effect, in which I might spend an hour reading, and then look at my percent through counter of Kindle and see that I was basically back where I started. This was not an easy read for me, to say the least. That being said, I think this book would be fabulous for someone studying the AIDS epidemic, or someone who simply enjoys academic studies more than I do. To me, this was a classic case of great book, but just the wrong fit for someone like me.

7 out of 10

Tuesday, May 30, 2017

Ghosts by Raina Telgemeier Review + A Mini Review of Dare to Disappoint by Ozge Samanci

WARNING: THERE MAY BE SPOILERS BELOW

Catrina and her family are moving to the coast of Northern California because her little sister, Maya, is sick. Cat isn't happy about leaving her friends for Bahía de la Luna, but Maya has cystic fibrosis and will benefit from the cool, salty air that blows in from the sea. As the girls explore their new home, a neighbor lets them in on a secret: There are ghosts in Bahía de la Luna. Maya is determined to meet one, but Cat wants nothing to do with them. As the time of year when ghosts reunite with their loved ones approaches, Cat must figure out how to put aside her fears for her sister's sake - and her own. 

I'm not really a graphic novel fan. As much as I love art and animation and all that, graphic novels never really caught my eye. Maybe it's because graphic novel art reminds me a lot of the new Cartoon Network art, which is kind of unappealing to me. Also, a lot of graphic novels just kind of blend together and none of them stand out when I browse for books at my local library. 

But this month I read not one but two graphic novels. And I remembered another reason why I don't usually read graphic novels, but I'll get to that in a second. This is the first, which I picked up on a whim and also because, as I think I mentioned before, I really enjoy Raina Telgemeier's work. She's one of the few middle grade writers who have managed to hold my interest, and I find her art style unique and pleasant for a graphic novel. I especially like her memoirs, though I did also enjoy Drama, her first middle grade straight up novel. 

So with all that in mind I picked up Ghosts. I was intrigued by this book when it first came out in the September of last year, but then got distracted by other books that came out around that time, like A Gentleman in Moscow and Crooked Kingdom. I liked the fact that it was about a little girl with cystic fibrosis and her older sister dealing with the very real possibility that her sister will not live very long. I've never read a book that had a girl with cystic fibrosis in it, though I was aware of its existence, and really liked that representation. I also liked the Mexican cultural elements. Latin, especially Mexican, culture is so vibrant and colorful and quite interesting. Also, the Day of the Dead is easily one of the most interesting holidays out there, and I was a little in love with the Northern California town she created to set her story in- I'd never live in California, but if I had to, it'd be to there. Or San Francisco. Either one. 

That being said, my favorite part was the illustrations. I loved Telgemeier's take on ghosts. I admit, I expected a more realistic style of drawing ghosts and was really happy when I saw those cute little things. I also really liked her character designs and how she goes to extra lengths to make sure that all of her characters, even the background ones, are visually interesting and unique. 

Of course, this book does have flaws. It is a middle grade book, and a graphic novel, so the emotions don't reach as deep as they could have been. The characters aren't as developed as they could have been, and their development was pretty instantaneous. Both of these are common problems I have with graphic novels- I find that they're usually pretty short, and as such are pretty surface level in terms of depth. Often I leave them wanting more. 

But overall, I did enjoy this book, about as much I can enjoy a middle grade graphic novel. Also, ghosts. I really love ghosts. I'm tempted to pick up Anya's Ghost now because of this book. Recommended for any middle grade reader, graphic novel lover or not.

7.5 out of 10

And now, a mini review of Dare to Disappoint by Ozge Samanci

Growing up on the Aegean Coast, Ozge loved the sea and imagined a life of adventure while her parents and society demanded predictability. Her dad expected Ozge, like her sister, to become an engineer. She tried to hear her own voice over his and the religious and militaristic tensions of Turkey and the conflicts between secularism and fundamentalism. Could she be a scuba diver like Jacques Cousteau? A stage actress? Would it be possible to please everyone including herself?

In her unpredictable and funny graphic memoir, Ozge recounts her story using inventive collages, weaving together images of the sea, politics, science, and friendship.
 

Not crazy about this book. It had a lot of the same problems as Ghosts, but with a storyline that endeared me less and with what seemed like much less heart. I felt like Samanci just wrote this book because of the success of books along the same lines as this, like Persopolis (haven't read that one, and honestly, it doesn't really appeal much to me). 

I also felt that Samanci didn't really know where she was going with this book. Did she want to write a book about her father's pressure on her, fundamental Islam, a picture of Turkey at the time, what? The book felt as confused as Turkey did during the 80s. The lack of her telling us any time periods confused me, and made this not the best book for someone interested in a history of modern Turkey. Perhaps that's intentional, to mimic her feelings about what she should do with her life, but I don't know.

So what did I like? It was easy to read- I read the whole thing in one sitting without even checking it out because I was tired of my other book- and the mixed media elements were interesting even if it did add to the confused, jumbled together nature of the book. Some parts were actually pretty funny, but other times her jokes missed the mark a bit. My favorite parts were at the beginning of the book, when she talked about her experiences in primary school- the book kind of lost me as she entered her teenage years.

But the art style was mostly unpleasant and the ending felt unfinished and I left this book feeling very meh. I suppose if I want to read a book about Middle Eastern culture (I'm referring to the Middle East more as a cultural construct, not a geographical one in this context, because I know that Turkey isn't part of the Middle East geographically and people get all butthurt about it), I'd pick up something by Khaled Hosseini. His books are longer, and they lack the pictures, but his characters and portrayals of their situations are unmatched. Adore his stuff.

5-5.5 out of 10